25/35

Best Candy:

Justin's Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Slightly sweetened, vanilla-tinged peanut butter is stuffed into a cute little Rainforest Alliance Certified dark chocolate coating. Bonus: We love Justin's commitment to source sustainable palm oil, too.

Finalists:

• Little Secrets Dark Chocolate Candies
• JJ's Sweets Chocolate Covered Cocomels Vanilla